https://venezuelanalysis.com/news/venezuelan-armed-forces-bomb-eln-guerrilla-camp-reports/
The operation allegedly relied on US intelligence support, with open-access flight radar confirming the presence of US reconnaissance aircraft in Venezuelan territory.
The Venezuelan armed forces reportedly attacked a camp belonging to Colombia’s National Liberation Army (ELN) in the Pedro Camejo municipality, Apure State, on Friday.
The military operation relied on US intelligence support, according to Stratfor-owned geopolitical and intelligence platform RANE Worldview.
The interior minister additionally rejected any foreign interference in Venezuelan affairs. However, open-access flight radar confirmed the presence of US military assets in Venezuelan territory in recent days, including reconnaissance planes spotted flying over border areas.
Since the January 3 US attack and kidnapping of President Nicolás Maduro, senior US military brass have visited the Caribbean country, including Southern Command Commander General Francis Donovan and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Dan Caine.
In June, US forces conducted an airstrike in Bolívar State that they claimed to have extrajudicially executed Héctor “Niño” Guerrero, an alleged leader of the Tren de Aragua gang. Washington thanked Caracas for “cooperation,” while the Venezuelan government issued a statement informing of a “joint operation.”
Whole article:
Caracas, November 2, 2026 (venezuelanalysis.com) – The Venezuelan armed forces reportedly attacked a camp belonging to Colombia’s National Liberation Army (ELN) in the Pedro Camejo municipality, Apure State, on Friday.
The military operation relied on US intelligence support, according to Stratfor-owned geopolitical and intelligence platform RANE Worldview.
Local NGO Fundaredes stated the operation involved drones and combat helicopters and left 19 people killed, 10 of whom were identified by the forensic police in the state capital, San Fernando.
Fundaredes’ Apure director Javier García alleged that the ELN uses the area as a drug storage and logistics point. Right-wing news portal Infobae claimed that the attack also targeted camouflaged drug-transporting aircraft belonging to the ELN.
On Sunday, Fundaredes reported “armed clashes” which included drones in the Cedeño municipality of Bolívar State, close to the operations of state-owned bauxite mining and processing company BAUXILUM. According to Fundaredes, local miners were forced to leave the area and operations were temporarily suspended. However, the NGO did not identify who conducted the attacks.
The Venezuelan government and armed forces have not issued statements on the reported altercations in Apure and Bolívar. The Communications Ministry did not reply to a request for comment.
Venezuelan Interior Minister Diosdado Cabello said at a press conference on Monday that the country’s army and security forces had been deployed along the 2,200-kilometer border with Colombia to “prevent” any fallout from increased “conflict” in Colombia.
“We do not want any conflicts that are not ours,” Cabello said. He did not address the reports of an operation against the ELN.
The interior minister additionally rejected any foreign interference in Venezuelan affairs. However, open-access flight radar confirmed the presence of US military assets in Venezuelan territory in recent days, including reconnaissance planes spotted flying over border areas.
Since the January 3 US attack and kidnapping of President Nicolás Maduro, senior US military brass have visited the Caribbean country, including Southern Command Commander General Francis Donovan and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Dan Caine.
In June, US forces conducted an airstrike in Bolívar State that they claimed to have extrajudicially executed Héctor “Niño” Guerrero, an alleged leader of the Tren de Aragua gang. Washington thanked Caracas for “cooperation,” while the Venezuelan government issued a statement informing of a “joint operation.”
The Trump administration has not commented on the reported strikes against the Colombian armed group. During a September visit to Colombia, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio referred to the presence of the ELN and dissident factions of the demobilized Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) as an issue that “needs to be addressed” by Venezuelan authorities.
Since taking office in August, far-right Colombian President Abelardo de la Espriella has launched a “total offensive” against the ELN, with multiple airstrikes, security raids, and the militarization of Cúcuta, a major town on the border with Venezuela. It has also joined the Washington-led and funded “Shield of the Americas,” a regional alliance with an express goal of cracking down on transnational crime and migration.
For its part, the rebel group has vowed to resist and condemned US intervention in the region.
The ELN is the longest active guerrilla group in Colombia, having sustained a decades-long insurgency against the Colombian state. The organization maintained an arms-length relationship with the Bolivarian government under Chávez and Maduro, operating across the vast southwestern border uncontrolled by both nations and at times cooperating with Venezuelan authorities against Colombian paramilitaries and dissident FARC elements.
The Nicolás Maduro government supported former Colombian President Gustavo Petro’s efforts to negotiate a peace agreement with the ELN, with multiple negotiating rounds held in Caracas. However, hostilities from both sides persisted and the talks broke down.
Venezuelan authorities have repeatedly denied the sustained presence of Colombian armed groups on their side of the border. In 2021, the Venezuelan army launched an operation against dissident FARC elements in Apure State, with weeks of clashes causing dozens of casualties and thousands of displaced civilians. The ELN was widely rumored to have assisted in the operation.



To be honest I get the sense that both the Venezuela-with-Delcy defenders and Venezuela-with-Delcy decryers on this site know almost nothing about Venezuela and are picking fights to cover fragile egos (about not knowing anything about Venezuela).
I guess I’m a decryer (the defenders have called me much worse names, so I’ll take it) but I would like to make it known that I never claimed to be an expert on Venezuela. I know there are people here, including people in the Delcy Defender camp, that know a lot more about Venezuela than I do. My problem with all of this was not and is not that there are people here who firmly believe Delcy is carrying on the revolution. I actually still hope they’re right, though I can’t help but see with my own eyes what is happening and see that it is constantly becoming less and less tenable to hold that position.
Even if they were to believe Lenin will soon come back from the dead and save us all, I would still just look at them as being a bit kooky but I would not consider them to be adversaries or enemies, comrades that need to learn a few things sure, but so long as they are still fighting for liberation and fighting to bring about communism, I would still look to them as comrades. For example, I consider myself a Marxist Leninist but I still consider principled and knowledgeable anarchists to be my comrades, despite some fundamental differences and disagreements. The fact that I disagree with their takes on Venezuela is not what I have a problem with (though I do think they have a problem with me simply because of that disagreement).
What I do have a problem with is being told (literally, this happened more than once) to “just shut up,” I think one time it was “shut the fuck up” but maybe my memory is adding the expletive. I have a problem with being called an ultra, I have a problem with being called a liar and instigator, I have a problem with being called worse things I don’t want to repeat here. I have a problem with being ridiculed and silenced, all simply because I do not believe in their version of reality. I have a problem with not being allowed to discuss the possibility that AES countries can sometimes make mistakes or not be able to imply that they are not infallible. I have a problem with their burning disdain and derision towards me and towards anyone who doesn’t fully swallow the narrative they have developed on Venezuela. I have a problem with being compared to fucking Zionists just because I think this leadership in Venezuela does not have the best interests for the revolution in mind when they do these things that the US is demanding of them. But to people like my harasser, that is a crime deserving of their hatred and deserving of hounding me off the site. I have a problem with being told I’m not allowed to discuss my thoughts as a Marxist Leninist - imperfect but improving - about what’s happening without being told I’m essentially stupid and evil and literally that I “want all Venezuelans to die” which is a common refrain when anyone has the audacity to question the Delcy Defenders. They say if we don’t believe that Venezuela is in the right hands and the revolution is being protected, then we obviously must want every Venezuelan citizen to die a horrible death being martyred by the US, when of course we want nothing of the sort. But that’s what people get told, especially in the news mega, if they go against this absurd narrative they’ve cooked up. One user who is active in the newsmega and always posts fascinating and illuminating comments, u/InexplicableLunchFiend, was called a white supremacist! For the crime of disagreeing with the narrative.
People would ask simple questions and would get harshly berated for daring to wonder if Delcy and the cabinet were maybe making bad decisions or asking about opening up for US capital, or for privatizing national assets. People had (and still do) have to walk on eggshells so as not to rile up the wrath of a select few users who will go ballistic with their scorn and derision. If you care to, you can see some of this if you go into my history (which another user in this thread said the Delcy-Can-Do-No-Wrong Clique are using against me somehow, which is laughable because I have talked about all kinds of maybe silly things but nothing bad or out of line with good hexbear standards over the past five years I’ve had this account - though I’ve been around hexbear since its founding, and on the CTH sub before that.) Apparently they’re frothing about me right now, beneath my comment in the newsmega sharing this same article as I did for this post. This is the kind of behavior I won’t put up with.
That’s why I decide to de-lurk and make a post when I see something happening with Venezuela that very clearly demonstrates the absurdity of their position. It’s not a “gotcha! You were wrong, nyea nyeah!” it’s just showing how their narrative is becoming less and less tenable with each new Venezuela-related newsworthy event. And how misdirected their sheer hatred of me and others really is. I’m simply posting news about what is going on, which is exactly what this comm is supposed to be about. And yes, part of the impetus for posting about Venezuela specifically is because it’s my only way of fighting back (since I won’t stoop to their level of bile and cruelty), fighting back against that abject disgust they have for me and for @Awoo@hexbear.net and for @InexplicableLunchFiend@hexbear.net , and for a bunch of others who I don’t know if they would want to be named here, just because we disagree with the dominant clique’s faltering narrative.
Both “sides” of this issue are not the same, and even regardless of “who is right” they are still the ones being inexcusably despicable towards those of us they should embrace as comrades despite disagreement on this topic. So no, it’s not about two sides and neither one knows much about Venezuela but thinks they do. Like I said, I have MUCH to learn about Venezuela, and I would even be glad if by some miracle that defies recent events, that the other group was right. I would be very very happy if Delcy somehow turned all this into something genuinely beneficial for the Bolivarian movement, for the Chavismos, for the communes and for the Venezuelan people. However, my harasser and the followers would love to just spit in my face no matter what ends up happening because somehow I deeply offended them by not agreeing with their supposedly superior ability to do material analysis that the rest of us Marxist Leninists are just incapable of.
That’s a massive wall of text, I know, but I really did just want to get it out there and explain what’s really going on and explain my position in all this, partly because I know there are lies being told about me right now (most of which I can’t see because I blocked the worst offender). So I hope that if anyone cares enough to want to understand what’s happening here, that this helped clear things up.
https://hexbear.net/comment/7487443
Really funny for you to talk so much shit when this comment of yours exists.
You have fabricated so much and been proven wrong and are still committed to lying and pearl clutching when people prove you to be a liar and an instigator. It really is pathetic
Just to clarify I am not personally focusing on any one user, and my subtext is the extent to which people are developing strong opinions on very little information and then getting petty with one another. I think you will likely find something there that resonates with your experience here lol, and at the risk of both-sidesing there is a “doomer” version as well but again not focusing on any one user nor accusing any one user.
I think there is a (Western?) urge to have and share opinions to feel valid or part of a conversation, and to make those opinions stron and come across as thoroughly-backed. This can clash with a need to be accurate on topics that are important for developing lines, like avoiding both (light) national chauvinism and overcompensating via defense of wrong (or potentially wrong) actions of countries run by socialists.
My opinion is that we are getting a trickle of information that is negative but not catastrophic unless it develops more seriously in the future. Because that information is a trickle and is early signs more than huge disasters (maybe barring some of the actions re: Cuba, but I need to research that more thoroughly), it has to be understood in the specific context of Venezuelan society and political economy, which is something I don’t think anyone here understands. It’s not something one understands via Chavista statements of 800 words nor early news articles low on context, but people are reacting to those things hot.
My read for a few years now is that post chavez the venezuelan government were larpers and not actually socialist. Maduro wasnt good, delcy isnt good and now the us has their claws in venezuela so its over.
The venezuelan peoples general take away is that socialism is bad despite fighting against it for its entirety and never really knowing it. Most dont know Marx or care. Just bc youre from a country doesnt mean youre an authority on it, ex. MAGA have no business in any serious discussion. Anti-left venezuelans are the same with the political memory of a goldfish. Venezuela always sucked and always had immense problems, hence the desire for socialism but these people will tell you a place with 60%-80% illiteracy rate and high poverty rates was actually good.
Its a complete failure. Maduro probably sold his country out.
This is a more rational take than the ones who are constantly trying to blame a single figurehead of the government for all the problems. Venezuela has always been a weak socialist nation that has struggled because of their lack of follow through in their own affairs, going back to Chavez. Never supporting Venezuela makes more sense than saying you did support them and then changing course in 2026
Venezuelans were highly resistant to socialism straight from the get go and a lot of the boug’s abandoned ship right away doing a wealth/brain drain that fucked them pretty bad ontop of Chavez dying too soon, america sanction/embargoing, idiot opportunist leadership and a population that voted for socialism but never actually understood it.
i think it’s okay to support them and come to jesus on it now, venezuela fucked it up and honestly it’ll probably fuck Cuba up too.
quite honestly, the whole situation has put me in the mindset that good things will never happen and that all i can do is just try to enjoy my life before it’s over.
I’ve listened and read a lot of interviews with Chavistas on the ground and they cite Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Minh, and others regularly. Years of sanctions has made governing a barely existing nation incredibly difficult, and they didn’t repress their opposition enough from the get go, nor did they diversify their economy enough or focus enough on domestic production. It is all in hind sight, who knows how realistic these were as options if they thought of them at the time. Its not like they took over an already successful and powerful nation, they took over a neo colonial outpost that was run terribly from inception.
I think comparing it to Cuba is a good comparison because it isn’t that they personally gave up on their movement, but both nations have been under embargo and sanctions for so long that they are truly just unable to function as a basic state. both nations can’t provide basic life needs to their people, for decades. there isn’t much they could have done to make this any different, and they certainly were trying. it’s not like Assad in Syria who we can look back to and see kind of gave up a long time ago, we really can’t say that about Cuba or Venezuela despite the failures.
trying to enjoy your life is better than being a doomer about it but I believe in the people and can’t give up on our inevitable success, even if I don’t get to see it myself in this lifetime.
I know a lot of venezuelans personally and every single one of them doesnt know marx and hates Chavez/Maduro. Like theyre kind of just idiots, they dont care about anything and are easily swayed by social media Gusano in florida with shiny teeth saying Socialism Bad.
The difference with Venezuela and vietnam, russia, china, cuba is that they fought for their revolution. The venezuelan people again never really understood socialism and never understood why they needed to fight.
Venezuelan voted for theirs without knowing what socialism was or what it entails and right, they never did anything meaningful with their opposition. Infact they kind of let their bougs come and go from the US and Venezuela.
They will learn now with the US claws embedded in Venezuela
idk “venezuelans are just idiots” isn’t really compelling for me personally but if thats what drives your perspective go off i guess
Same way that Americans are idiots
Are the Venezuelans you know immigrants? The Venezuelan diaspora is more liberal and reactionary than people in Venezuela itself. Notoriously, even, in LatAm, where they do embarrassing pro-US protests and have to get shouted down by local leftists.
I do not know whether the masses in Venezuela are particularly in top of socialist theory or geopolitics (clearly many Chavistas and communes are), but it would not be a massive issue if they were not. Socialist parties in leadership have the task of not just education but of focusing on the needs of the population and enjoining them in struggle. That seems to happen in Venezuela, though the struggle is likely a harder battle due to the prevalence of bourgeois interests. Communes have to be their own enforcers on many issues, like physically and coercively.
It’s important to remember that these are common struggles, not a post-mortem on “what went wrong”. Largely speaking I don’t think folks here know much about what has actually been happening on the ground in order to state what was a mistake or not. But the important thing is that this is not simply an internal organizing issue of PSUV or its leadership, but a wider struggle against imperialism with many factions and good struggles that are not guaranteed to win even if they had taken the best steps possible. A neocolonized country transformed into an export economy by imperialists has an uphill battle to assert even modest levels of sovereignty. Their “crime” that led to mass sanctions and decades of pressure campaigns was nationalizing the oil industry rather than continuing to be foreign-owned and proceeds expropriated, not the specifics of how they organize government or society. And that struggle continues, it is not over.
Every single one is green card status and came within the last ten years
I don’t think that really makes a difference.
I’ve based all my analysis on material evidence and have provide evidence disproving the many fabrications of the opposition voices here over and over again. Unlike those people, I’ve been keenly aware of Venezuela for more than a few months, and can prove that with my understanding of the nation both historically and over the last year. This is why those who disagree with me have never engaged with my positions and counter arguments and instead rely on logical fallicies, and making things up.
Edit: There is one side who immediately decided delcy was a comprador and did a coup and despite there being no evidence for such a thing almost a year later they still stick to it, and the other side’s entire position is “we need material evidence to support our analysis as Marxists instead of making things up.” None of us have “defended” any great man or woman because we are actually marxists, and the other side exclusively makes things up, editorialized and cherry picks to support their points. Trying to be an enlightened centrist about this is pretty silly
It’s not enlightened centrism to notice the pettiness and extremity often on display that does not actually match substantive knowledge of the nation, and that both sides go out of their way to pick fights. I proposed that this is due to insecurity and tendencies to attach one’s ego to being a X-knower, where X has something to do with socialism, even when there just isn’t that much to back it up. Perhaps there are other reasons to fail to communicate in a minimally comradely way that builds through criticism. There are other detects in this aside from form but I’d rather not mention them to avoid singling people out, as folks are already primed to be defensive.
I see it as putting one’s ego first, or personal frustrations. Unserious behavior that would not be tolerated in most communist orgs. Perhaps you have another explanation.
When the OP of this thread made up lies about me in the exchange that they blocked me, I made it a point to go back and read my entire post history of the last year in search of any evidence that I was missing something about my own behavior that didn’t line up with how I am remembering my own experience here.
In all of my initial interactions I was not personal, petty, insulting or displaying some lack of knowledge on the topic. I have been very clear about what evidence I have to support my analysis and what my speculation is, and why I believe it. At this point that is split among many different posts but it’s all out there.
The only time I start to get more aggressive against people is when they reveal themselves to have reactionary positions and refuse to engage in any sincere, honest attempt at discussing it. In every case, those users start the attacks, they start they petty, they fabricate things and intentionally misinterpret others. The record is clear to me and many others here, most of who rightfully don’t want to spend any energy devoted to this here but nonetheless make it clear I’m not alone in my perspective. I have had regular disagreements with plenty of users here that didn’t devolve into anything petty, because this users weren’t being wreckers, they just disagreed.
You are imagining that we would be in the same org to have this interaction. These people wouldn’t make it through our introductary political education process without revealing themselves to be reactionaries. They don’t ever make it into the organization in the first place. This happens every week with weirdo fringe pseudo leftists who finally decide to try organizing for the first time and then try and push their agendas. They don’t make it to the part where we have to debate internally because they have inundated themselves so deeply with their head canon that they can’t be disagreed with without fully crashing out. Our internal debate process is extremely comradely because we have all proven ourselves to each other and have trust. These posters have shown themselves to be wreckers through their behavior and a nearly year long commitment to blatantly making things up to convince people to abandon a non white revolutionary movement.
This is more like when an organization tries to be in a coalition space with a lib pseudo leftist group that doesn’t do any real organizing but tries to insert themselves into coalition spaces to exploit the work of the organizers and claim credit for things they don’t actually contribute to. This also happens all the time with ultras, radlibs, anarchists, or dem soc clubs that push their agendas and ultimately wreck the work of everyone who is serious about accomplishing the coalition’s goals. In the coalition spaces we would communicate professionally about it but behind the scenes we would absolutely ridicule these people, clock them as reactionaries, and make sure they aren’t continuing to infiltrate the spaces we work in.
It seems your issue with what I am saying is that you want to assert it does not apply to you, thus making what I am saying into a more specific discussion about you or your past behavior - presumably simply agreeing whether it applies or not. I suggested that the pattern of picking fights and being petty was applying broadly, your response is, “I don’t do that!” I suppose there is some fairness in that response but it does mean navigating away from discussing what it means to interface with each other more productively or to try and recognize how something could apply in general and instead interrogating your posting history or something. I’m not convinced that is a productive use of time. It seems like, itself, a fairly petty thing, and the length of your response in invoking it doesn’t make me think it would be a healthy direction. But it seems there is no proceeding without being more specific or ceding ground, so I will address it a bit.
As an example, in our last interaction - and we have not had many - I had read one of your proclamations in the news mega and felt it was likely overstating what materials it was drawing from. I said this and asked if you had a stronger connection to on the ground information, as to me that would make it more justified. But I also suspected it was just overstatement and throwing shade in the process. Your response was evasive and then personally accusatory. Defensive behavior, not being forthright, and straw manning me, before finally accusing me of being a cop for simply asking if you had on the ground connections.
I think these kinds of interactions have been pretty common in the news mega, particularly on this topic since the US kidnapped Maduro, and aren’t unique to you or to me. There’s a streak of petty posting end escalation in Hexbear culture, one that rewarded the aesthetic of righteous dunking, that turns from productive criticism to trying to simply abuse others. Lots of sarcasm, lots of jumping thr gun. Could be “doomer” or “bloomer” on the topic. Edit: I want to note I’m guilty of this as well but I do try to recognize it and limit it in myself.
Regarding organizing: no, I am correct. This kind of behavior would be corrected in a communist org or the org would implode or self-limit from toxicity. I’ve seen it happen a few times among neighboring orgs via members that dual carded or ex-members I’m on friendly terms with. To be clear, Hexbear is not an org and has no discipline and therefore few hopes for much directed impact. I don’t think of anyone here as cadre or expect that of them. But I do think anyone can see the benefit in communicating constructively critically with comrades, certainly when drawing on years of experience navigating much more tense social organizing situations than these without lashing out at each other. Regarding coalition spaces, strategic communication is even more important in that context, the angle must always be what the org achieves through statements to coalition members and ultimately what the aims are of being in that coalition and how they’re served by that communication. When members bring personal invective to those spaces it is universally counterproductive and, in my experience without exception, pointlessly placing oneself as an individual before the needs of the org. I’m not listing any of these things as a personal criticism of you, only to point out that the grounded productive behavior in communist spaces is antithetical to what you’re trying to justify.
I’m not interested in a discussion about what it means to interface with wreckers and reactionaries more productively, which is why I can only really talk about my own experience here with engaging with those wreckers and make a case for why I choose to approach wreckers in that way. I was already clear I don’t initiate with anyone as if they are already wreckers, but if you are organizing and wreckers are afoot, allowing them space to wreck in the sake of “interfacing productively” with people who are caught fabricating information, lying about other people, and refusing to engage with the disagreements that they have with other people with sincerity or an openness to being wrong, is a strategic mistake and will cost countless hours of labor that is derailed from doing actually important work. I am doing my part in treating people with the respect they deserve and wreckers deserve little to none in my experience as an organizer.
I’m also not really interested in relitigating our last interaction, but I know I’m not the only user that got the same vibe from your comments, and I don’t think that is what straw manning is but you kind of do some straw manning there yourself by first asking me if I have direct connections with people in Venezuela, a very specific question, but later commented this: “I have direct connections to several overseas communist orgs. Did I just do a fed? Seems like it isn’t a particular risk to say that.”
answering a much less specific and entirely different question “do you have any connections to any overseas communist orgs?” which is not the question you asked me. you straw manned yourself there, changing the original premise to another and then acting like what I thought was unreasonable because of a different thing entirely than what you asked me. Do you see what I’m saying here? do you see how you asked me a specific personal questions about my personal connections to a specific place and then acted like it was unreasonable because you were willing to say pretty much nothing at all about your connections to anything specific at all? do you see how those are different but you intentionally presented them as the same to justify your perspective that I was being unreasonable?
yes Chana, I have connections with people somewhere, is that all you wanted to hear when you asked me about my personal relationship to Venezuelan organizers? Didn’t really seem like it but I guess that is somehow my bad.
I know they aren’t unique to me, that is why I do that here. I am participating in the culture here in the way that makes sense to me. I’m able to say what I can’t say in organizing to the people that deserve it, because I don’t have to be a professional organizer here, I’m just another anonymous liberal in a sea of the only real revolutionaries to ever exist. I can defend evidence based analysis and solidarity with revolutionary movements against people who are cowards and liars, without holding back. I’ve had comments moderated before and I trust they will be if I cross the line, but otherwise hexbear allows me to present my arguments, and argue them, and even point out when other people are lying and their arguments don’t make any sense. Doing that here is something I want to do because I think it is good for other, inexperienced organizers, to see. When I was first getting radicalized, seeing the arguments laid out and contested online was the only space to see any discussion on most topics at all. once I got into actual organizing work, most organizing spaces were totally unsafe to try to defend any former socialist movement because they were dominated by anarchists, dem socs, trots, and maoists. Outing yourself as a supporter of almost any historical revolutionary movement got you pinned as a “tankie” and that comes with a lot of stigma with those various radlibs cosplaying as revolutionaries.
now I am incredibly luckily to be able to work with almost no white people and very few men in a very large and robust project that every person there would ridicule the shit out of some loser like the ones here, while also out organizing them in every way, and just being a better person from the inside out. it would be a bonding exercise for us to talk shit about the absolutely trash takes these people have while making sure that everyone we work in coalition with knows who is snooping around our community spreading vitriol. Every week a new micro group of 2 ultras tries to prey on college kids here and start some new reading group where they try and teach people what is correct instead of how to come to correct conclusions on their own, because they can’t get into the legitimate organizations in this area because every one of them knows how to vet a recruit and keep out these types of people. and every week we clown on those people because they deserve it, and it brings us closer together as we actually do the work that those clowns will never be involved with because no one in the real world wants to talk to them after they get to know them.
I don’t know what you think I said you were incorrect about, but go off I guess. I thought I was clear on this part of the topic.
yeah but they aren’t comrades, that is the point. I have made this clear, why do so many people here just glaze over what I am saying without reading it?
How do I communicate constructively with someone who has blocked me because they don’t want to read what I said and instead want to make shit up? Because they crash out and say really wild shit online when people disagree with them? look at my original posts with all these people, I was very constructive. why do I have to be the only one to keep that up? these people are peddlers of misinformation, conspiracies, and metaphysical analysis. every argument they have presented has been debunked and they refuse to even try to debunk the arguments of others, instead relying entirely on insults and lies. do you really think we need to “be civil” with these people in perpetuity?
In my one actual example of unproductive engagement, you were engaging with me. So are you indirectly just calling me a wrecker or reactionary?
I do think the logic you’ve listed is explanatory of the behavior either way, though. Also not unique to you. The other person is at the extreme opposite, they’re the enemy. I don’t think anyone would take this seriously given that it would seemingly apply to someone like Awoo, but defending such demonization is a part of justifying abusive behavior.
Using “wreckers” in this way is a larp and means nothing. It is even less applicable to Hexbear than when I make allusions to how functional cadre have social discipline.
We are on a leftist shift posting site. Spending time here dumping on other users is surely more derailing of this actually important work than them simply existing and saying things could be, if that is the tradeoff. It doesn’t make a lot of sense to me that any amount of time spent on this website is anything other than a decision to be taking a break from actually important work. If the time spent here is being slotted under doing that work in any way, then my points on how to engage with others here stands. And, again, it is by no means just you, I am only responding to the “no that doesn’t apply to me” responses.
I do think that every person on this website that has treated others poorly has rationalized the others, hyperbolically, as enemies.
“I’m not interesting in relitigating, now let’s relitigate that one person agreed with me”. Sheesh.
I don’t believe you seriously thought I was asking you to haul a Venezuelan out to talk to me. That was just an exaggeration for effect to avoid giving a direct answer.
I do but that isn’t what a straw man is and I don’t see validity in the complaint. I address it after the next quote.
The only thing missing from my example, which again was in response to someone else, is a country rather than “overseas”. If this is your example - and it is not at all a straw man - I can mention one. Ties to communist groups in China, as an example. But to reiterate, I’m not hounding you for a ‘yes’ or ‘no’, and didn’t back then either. I was just pointing out my own comfort level and how it feels like a reasonable thing to ask, not that I demand you give me that information - I would have respected “I won’t ansewr that” or just ignoring me. I pushed back on evasive responses, straw men, petty accusations.
It’s actually just me giving an example of how I don’t feel it is a significant infosec issue to ask, let alone one meriting calling someone else a fed or cop, and… again that response wasn’t even to you, unless you are saying oliveoil is your alt.
Again I didn’t press you for the information, just an honest response. I am not asking you the question now. I actually got a sufficient answer to my underlying question just from how that interaction went down. Sometimes you can get all you need just from trying to have a direct conversation, even with no resolution.
An inconsistency. The logic of whether your perceived enemies (other hexbear users professing communist things) “deserve it” is a distraction from whether it is strategic communication that builds (as opposed to constructive criticism) rather than bait and personal attack. You defensively lashed out at me, so I know for certain that your estimates on who “deserves it” are faulty.
Do you directly call coalition members fabricators and liars in coalition meetings? I don’t see the relevance of any of this re: hexbear. You are simultaneously presenting public communications here as analogous to insider shit-talking while also being an external coalition context where the wreckers and enemies all exist to be righteously categorized and insulted.
You were responding to me saying this “Unserious behavior that would not be tolerated in most communist orgs.” I am responding to the entirety of your two paragraphs there trying to build on analogies of intra-org, inter-org, etc contexts to seemingly justify how actually these negative interactions are not at all in contradiction of discipline in a functional org, but that’s mostly irrelevant, per my explanation.
If they blocked you then neither form of communication is really on the table any longer. I cannot give constructive feedbck to that without interrogating the block and to be honest I don’t think either of us expect repair of “relationships” via these usernames. The damage is already done, the tendency to create micro-factions (to the extent this is a real thing on a shitposting site) has already kicked off from it. That is a common outcome of this kind of communication prior to the block.
Well, while it sucks, this is basically the neverending responsibility of cadre. The thing we spend the most effort on is having strategic conversations when we know the other person or people are wrong in 10 different ways. I don’t require you to take on an unfair burden in this, but if you’r saying it’s 200% more communist to be interacting this way, I say it is the exact opposite. I can look over those other conversations again and try to understand them as best I can - do you just mean the ones you linked in this thread - but I do have to note that my personal experience already gives one data point in the opposite direction.
I can guarantee some of your positions include all of those things as well. None of us have all of the right takes, nor are free from the tendency to adopt opinions before having good enough information. I am not trying to simply equate, as that would require diving into all of the specifics, but I would suggest having at lesat as much grace for others as you expect for yourself is a good thing to model.
I’m not appealing to civility.
No I’m not, there are plenty of people here I’ve openly disagreed with, the wrecker behavior is when we get into the types of actions I’ve already described at length and continually point out as it happens.
When it comes to anyone individually, i have been up front about what I think, it hasn’t felt indirect
Call it larp all you want, I deal with people like this more in the real world than I do online and I’m glad to be able to identify who are truly foes and who are committed to a revolutionary struggle greater than themselves. I’m thankful the failures of the past have helped to avoid more loss from these types of people. Navigating the reality that most of the Westernized leftists you’ll meet in the real world are actually going to betray their self proclaimed beliefs for personal gain has a steep learning curve. When people take such intense stances on things they don’t know about, and the stances are so clearly wrong and without material evidence, they are saying a lot about themselves as individuals.
I’m pretty openly poking fun at my own masochistic desire to be this way on hexbear, and taking breaks from work is a good thing to do. Are you suggesting that taking any breaks is some betrayal of the important work? This purity stuff is a big part of the problem, as many have pointed out. I’m here doing this because I want to, it’s something I like to do, despite most of my faves being pushed out due to Zionism and white supremacy, I’m still here clocking for a little while longer. Hopefully others will keep it up when I inevitably lose interest and move on to other things, otherwise hexbear will be dominated by reddit tier takes as the many great users here slowly get tired of the bullshit.
You are really saying there is no correlation between what you are saying in that comment and what you had just been saying to me in the same thread before? You really can’t see how what I said makes sense?
Not really sure how to engage without the ability to understand each other. You are making a lot of assumptions, misinterpreting what I’ve said, putting words in my mouth… And you are presenting it all in a way that feels very pedantic. If you want to apply the same fervor to the actual topic at hand I will engage with that but the attempt at meta analysis would need more mutual understanding to be fruitful.
I’ve written a lot now about what my actual positions are, why, and provided counter arguments to every one that I could. I did most of this in an entirely comradely manner and no one who disagree has really even tried to engage with it.
For me this is all an exercise is practicing dialectical materialist analysis and applying it within a space where others utilize the same framework and also have a sense of humor. It’s like a leftish news source and a puzzle in one, but instead of a crossword it’s simulator for Marxist analysis and sometimes debate. I get to do mini research projects over the course of weeks where I am studying a subject, writing regularly about it and refining my understanding as information is discovered that changes the calculus. I’m actually trying to learn what is going on and get all the data and become educated so that I can have better political positions, be better at educating my comrades and the masses, and helping to elevate the voices of the people who are being silenced by white supremacy and imperialism. It feels like a productive use of my time to stay current on what is going on day to day and practice forming my own opinions based on evidence I have, and it’s really cool and affirming when other people do the same thing independently and we come to the same conclusions.
This is why it is so frustrating to see people doing the opposite over and over again. If they were applying a marxist framework to prove their positions it would be contributing to the overall culture in a positive way, but by rejecting that entirely they are normalizing a subculture of just purely vibes wish casting which is inherently anti-marxist and kind of ruins the vibe for those of us actually trying to contribute utilizing dialectical materialism.
Okay then. I do disagree with your later characterization that you have simply been up front as our most recent prior interaction was the opposite of that.
I suppose it is sometimes. I think it just requires one failure so long as you follow it up with education. Sometimes good organizing is letting newish members try some bad ideas (non risky ones) because you know that you can do a useful postmortem that covers why it didn’t work and why you didn’t commit much resources to it. I think there is a substantial disconnect between what words people use, picking up the lexicon of a subculture, vs their actual understand commitment. I don’t think many think of it as a betrayal at all, they didn’t actually change their positions, they just didn’t adopt correct principals in the first place. Consistently aligned with their petty bourgeois-adjascent career trajectories.
No. I’m not telling you to do anything re: maximizing your organizing time. Just looking at internal inconsistency in what you say about it. Justifications that don’t make sense.
I agree that this place harbors many wrong ideas, usually liberal ones. There has still been no reckoning with the liberal Zionism among the mods.
Saying replies to someone else were replies to you does not make sense, no. I responded to the content anyways as if it was between us, though, so you could engage with that if you wanted to.
When? How so? If the goal is communication you would need to say how.
I don’t know what would be pedantic here aside from me disagreeing with you and offering crit on toxic behaviors - that, again, were not actually specifically targeted at you.
I don’t know what this means.
For the next two paragraphs I see you explaining your own view of what you’re doing, I think redundantly. But I don’t understand how it is a response to my previous comment. Maybe I should clarify that I am not overly invested in any Hexbear user’s personal journey, though I wish people here the best in general. But I will point out the flaws in toxic behaviors. Such as my original point that the claims people are making about Venezuela do not comport with the underlying knowledge. Not all equally in every way on all subtopica, but definitely by all “sides”, and I see patterns that this is due to egos and things like attaching one’s identity to being a knowledge-haver, a take-giver, etc. Sometimes just, “well I see something disagreeing with my general opinion and that pisses me off”. Then people begin weaponizing things like their identities in an anonymous internet forum where nobody knows each other, trying to find an angle to dunk with sympathy. Fundamentally a liberal behavior, that is their bread and butter escape hatch. If you participate in coalition spaces you will have run into this.
Re: frustrations at people being wrong on the internet, that is why our role is education, ideally organizing people into education work if it is important to us. Flinging shit at people is always tempting, but it is also, in my experience, always counterproductive in the end.