Muinteoir_Saoirse [she/her]

Educator/Múinteoir (she/elle/sí)

  • 0 Posts
  • 22 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 26th, 2025

help-circle



  • Because the people of the US are materially interested in attacking others. You talk about yourself as some great material analyst, but come on. Actually look at the demographics you’re talking about, actually learn how people are in the US and China, the lives they lead, the things they think, their material conditions and their class interests. It’s pretty obvious why the US can convince people to go to war, and why China would struggle to get popular support for foreign intervention. The US is propped up by violence, it feeds them. China is propped up by peaceful trade. You can’t just “analyze” your way out of how people relate to the world around them and how people would feel about being asked to get involved in a war.


  • They are made up of people. And I can guarantee you that the people of China aren’t interested in being at war with Israel, so what is the nation-state supposed to do? It’s all well and good to call yourself materialist, but the material conditions of the average Chinese citizen doesn’t lend towards them wanting to die in Iran. So what, should China try to impose militarism on its populace? It’s easy to demand violent intervention, war, and foreign imposition when that’s how capitalist nations operate, but when it’s you and your family being asked to give up your currently peaceful life to die for people you’ve never met…well most of the people here baying for blood certainly wouldn’t do it, most people here would hardly deprive themself of a comfort, a convenience, or a treat unless forced to.

    Edit: and while we’re at it, you definitely didn’t do “everything within your power” if you’re asking other people to put their lives on the line but you’re safely here typing on Hexbear