Y’all know about Anarchist Nexus and Lumnous5481 putting “Murder all Zionists” in their display name, verbatim, leading to predictable strife with other instance personnel they were implicitly or explicitly calling to murder. I had several arguments here amounting to, it doesn’t really matter how bad you think the group in question is; you can’t just say ‘kill them all’ and act aghast when people have follow-up questions.
Two days after the last of these arguments, MysticMushroom1776 decided that ‘it’s not a matter of who’ was too apologistic, and banned me from all the communities they control. None of which I’ve ever posted in or care about. Okay.
I think I downvoted a post on MeanwhileOnWorld once, and if that’s the impetus, Christ, that’s sad.
It kinda does though. If you are killing children, stealing homes, bombing hospitals, destroying energy infrastructure or support the above then I don’t want you around.
We’re not talking about segregating based on immutable characteristics here, we’re talking about a group who’s identity is based in violence, abuse, and murder (not Jews, but Zionists–they are different).
A zionist in america not involved in the genocidal actions you mentionned do not deserve to die. Those involved is valid since they are terrorists
Advocating for genocide is a pretty terrible take. Would you recommend reeducation camps for them instead?
Yes it is pretty terrible but not to the point of killing them. Those advocating for genocide and not directly participating in it should be either jailed or fined. Those who are stealing Palestinians land and attacking Palestinians are valid target
Were the Nuremberg trials genocide?
I posit that stopping them from doing violence would be cultural genocide against Zionists.
Edit: I replied to the wrong comment
Okay great, but when that means “I wish someone would murder the admins of other instances,” those instances will respond in predictable ways, regardless of how good your reasons are.
For the murder fantasies.
It’s not a matter of who.
Agitating for justice against actual murderers, like Israeli Zionists, is not a case of one thing as as bad as the other, dingus.
And yet, when you call for murder, the people you’re calling to murder will have entirely unsurprising responses. When those people are in charge of websites, you don’t get to be on those websites anymore. Regardless of your moral righteousness, you have to temper your calls to action, if you want to avoid that blindingly obvious result.
Yes, and the single user who used that word did in fact temper their phrasing.
Maybe if an instance is modded by inhuman rape-and-genocide monsters it shouldn’t be federated? I feel like that’s reasonable. Its not as if there’s any benefit to dialogue with them.
… then what was the problem with them defederating from Anarchist Nexus? Congratulations, they did the thing for you.
I am in fact in favor of more complete defederation from them
deleted by creator