This is a thread specifically for the war, not a general megathread (use the pinned /c/genzedong thread for that).
Please keep related news in this thread rather than making separate posts. Remember to include sources and avoid spreading rumours.
This is a thread specifically for the war, not a general megathread (use the pinned /c/genzedong thread for that).
Please keep related news in this thread rather than making separate posts. Remember to include sources and avoid spreading rumours.
Commentary of Fortros Admin
🇮🇷🇺🇸🇦🇪🇱🇧🇨🇳| Well written analysis by Mahdi Kharratiyan, an Iranian political researcher, which closely fits together with what I wrote last night.
Expand
Here are some points I took with added annotations/extra’s of my own.
The US is returning to negotiations because of mounting pressure from financial markets and the Republicans’ heavy midterm defeat.
Iran has a rare opportunity to end the war from a position of strength, but is risking it by wasting it through repeating the same failed diplomatic approach.
The same repeated mistake: 1️⃣ Mediation proposal comes up during a critical moment. 2️⃣ Direct or indirect negotiations take place 3️⃣ Next, a flood of partially accurate and false reports reach the media, forcing the Iranian side to deny some or all of them 4️⃣ Finally, Iran finds itself in a position where it has no choice but to terminate the negotiations
Currently, and this is my opinion, we’re at stage 1 again where we experience a flood of reports regarding proposals to mediate Iran-US talks and a little of stage 3 where an influx of rumours are spread in the media, forcing Iran to deny them (example: Yesterday with the fake news on Mohsen Rezaee-Vance meeting)
The problem goes far beyond negotiations with Washington. Iran continues to treat Strait of Hormoz, Yemen, Lebanon and regional trade corridors as separate issues, while accommodating the UAE, which is actively undermining Iran’s leverage in the Strait of Hormoz.
The UAE is central to the US-backed IMEC corridor and Israel’s regional economic ambitions.
Allowing Emirati shipping networks to bypass Iran’s restrictions risks weakening Tehran’s control over Strait of Hormoz and strengthening Israeli influence.
Lebanon’s recent integration into the IMEC port network is particularly concerning, which could potentially pave the way for a Beirut–Haifa trade route and further pressure on Hezbollah and southern Lebanon.
Iran needs a comprehensive postwar strategy, not another narrow agreement with Washington.
China and Russia must play a central role in establishing a new regional security and economic order, reducing US and Israeli influence, and supporting alternative trade corridors linking Iran, Pakistan, Turkey, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon.
Relations with Saudi Arabia should also improve, provided its policies toward Yemen and Lebanon are addressed.
The nuclear issue must be reconsidered as part of this broader settlement.
Iran should reject permanent nuclear restrictions, preserve the option to withdraw from the NPT under Article X, and ensure that any concessions are immediately reversible. Nuclear restraint must be conditional on credible security guarantees, not unconditional promises.
Iran should retain military control of Strait of Hormoz while considering arrangements to share its commercial benefits with Persian Gulf states, provided China supports the development of Iranian ports, particularly Chabahar.
The biggest danger is losing the leverage Iran has already gained.
If negotiations merely calm oil and financial markets while Iran continues accommodating the UAE, Washington’s pressure will ease while Iran’s economic difficulties worsen. Tehran could ultimately face another war or be forced into far greater concessions.
The objective should be a durable regional settlement that breaks Iran’s pre-war dependence on the UAE, strengthens its geopolitical position, and guarantees its long-term security and economic development.
The US should be one part of that settlement, not its center.
@FotrosResistancee
https://t.me/FotrosResistancee/24579
I personally disagree with the framing of this analysis, particularly, I think that there isn’t any real deal that can produce he results that Iran seeks. The US is not a trustworthy actor in the slightest, and the only path that I see possible is of the military variety. I believe that the current IRGC leadership and the Supreme Leader, recognize this already, and so I do not think they are falling into the negotiation trap.
Iran doesn’t need negotiation leverage, it already has it, the issue isn’t Iran’s diplomatic positioning, it’s the fact that the US is a bad faith actor in every respect. Therefore, the only way for Iran to impose it’s demands on the US, is by physically dismantling the US presence in the region, something it’s already done a lot of.
As long as there are Yankees within striking distance if Iran, then their can be no negotiations because the US will try to reverse the situation to the prewar status quo. Every vessel must be in danger and the bases used by the US to maintain their limited presence must be made inoperable, until the US is pushed so far back that the logistics of maintaining their blockade is impossible.
The US does not negotiate, it only understands the language of force.
This analysis isn’t horrible mind you. I just feel it hyper-focuses too much on securing a structural change in West Asia through negotiations. I will say I agree with its assertion that the Iran should hold a harsher stance to the UAE. More importantly, I think Iran should deal with the oligarch controlled sector of the Iranian economy that is dependent on working with the UAE.
The issue is not about external relationship with the Emiratis, it’s the dependence that a portion of the Iranian bourgeoisie have on facilitating global trade through Emirati banks. The threat is an internal one, not external.
I want to make a point about striking distance from Iran.
It had been though 2000km was the limit of thier missiles due to technological limitations. I just saw an article stating that in fact it was a self imposed restriction due to a belief that any attacks would likely come from inside that radius. Now they know differently they have removed the self imposed restrictions and assured us that they have the technological knowhow to extend their missiles range significantly thus enabling them to attack any body who is involved with attacking them. I have to assume that if Australia uses pine gap to help attack them they would consider it a valid target and may send a few missiles at it. I for one look forward to hearing that iran has gifted my country a few missiles