• 0 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: February 3rd, 2024

help-circle



  • This is a sexist and unaware take. Women and girls deserve a distinct sports category for our safety and to ensure our opportunities aren’t taken by a male (which is currently happening). Kids have to meet all kinds of requirements to play sports already for other good reasons. Please speak about it directly if you don’t think women’s rights are a good reason.

    I don’t want to drag kids to hospitals as I said above, cheek swabs are a better method.





    • there are some immutable biological differences between males and females. weight/height classes and hormones/blockers don’t make these differences go away.
    • women and girls get fewer opportunities to succeed in sports, and letting a male take a spot from a female athlete is a form of bigotry and male supremacy.
    • just let women and girls have something for ourselves for once? males want to get in all our spaces and don’t know how to take “no” for an answer

  • “reproductive anatomy” refers to the whole system: internal (ovaries, fallopian tubes, uterus, cervix, vagina), and external (vulva)… though the internal anatomy is what is strictly required for reproduction. and for that reason, the gametes produced by either ovaries or testes are what determines what sex someone is. so if they’re trying to categorize sports based on sex and not gender, then an ultrasound to check for ovaries or testes (possibly internal testes), would make sense, as it is possible to have an external vulva but internal testes. so checking external genitals would be pretty unscientific, sometimes inaccurate, and privacy-invasive.

    as I was saying above, an ultrasound would be just one possible method for testing that the initiative mentions, but more likely the testing would be a cheek swab.


  • “reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels.”

    • reproductive anatomy - (ovaries or testes), can be checked via ultrasound.

    • genetic makeup - (chromosomes, presence of the SR-Y gene), can be checked via cheek swab. (easiest, least invasive, and the cheapest- so the most likely to be used.)

    • normal endogenously produced testosterone levels - can be checked via blood draw.

    where are you getting genital inspection from? likely the whole girls team will be lined up and cheek swabbed (like a covid test) and then they will recieve the results later privately. this doesn’t require a doctor’s appointment for each player, and is the easiest option.

    so genital inspections are not required and they are not mentioned in the initiative.